TABLE OF CONTENTS2.0 DEFINITION OF DOMESTIC VIOLENCE 2.1 Forms of Violence in Relationships 3.0 EFFECTS OF DOMESTIC VIOLENCE ON WOMEN AND CHILDREN 3.1 Effects on Women 4.0 WOMEN FROM SPECIFIC GROUPS 4.1 Pregnant Women 5.0 RECOGNISING DOMESTIC VIOLENCE 5.1 Physical Signs of Violence 6.0 ASSESSMENT AND CONFIDENTIALITY 7.0 HOW TO TALK TO YOU PATIENT 8.1 Physical Examination 12.0 DOMESTIC VIOLENCE AND THE LAW 1.0 INTRODUCTIONThis manual has been developed as a basic guide for General Practitioners. The manual aims to provide the practical knowledge and skills to best support patients who have experience domestic violence. While we acknowledge that not all survivors of domestic violence are female, research to date demonstrates that domestic violence is primarily perpetrated against women and children. Thus, when we talk in this manual about the victims or survivors of domestic violence we talk about women and children. Women are at a disproportionately high risk of physical, sexual and psychological violence from an intimate person such as a partner or ex-partner. Many children, too, are likely to experience violence from someone they know or to be witnesses to violence within their families. Health professionals are often the first ones outside of family and friends to whom victims of domestic violence turn to, placing health professionals in a central role in responding to domestic violence. The quality of care that a woman receives following a disclosure of domestic violence can have a direct bearing on her and her children's well being, and in some cases may increase their chances of survival. Identification of a woman as a victim is often made difficult by a woman's reluctance to discuss the issue of violence, even when there are presenting signs of abuse in the form of suspicious injuries. General Practitioners therefore, may have to rely on factors other than self-identification. We hope that this manual will be of assistance in this area. 2.0 DEFINITION OF DOMESTIC VIOLENCEDomestic violence can be defined as a situation where one partner in an intimate
relationship uses violence to control and dominate the other partner. It is
now accepted that domestic violence occurs extensively in Australia and that
it occurs across all age groups and cultures. How victims themselves define
domestic violence can be strongly mediated by cultural beliefs, values and previous
experiences of abuse, and may not coincide with standard definitions of domestic
violence in the literature. Domestic violence is characterised by the use of
coercive control and psychological abuse. The experience of victimisation is
therefore usually associated with modifications in the victim's perception of
the perpetrator, especially a belief in his power, and alterations in the victim's
perceptions of self. Feelings of self-blame, shame and loss of self-esteem are
extremely common. The perpetrator can at times act in a kind manner towards
the victim, which can give false hopes to the abused that the violence will
end (Atsbury, J; Atkinson, J. & Duke, J.E: 2000;
http://www.mja.com.au/public/issues/astburb.html). Domestic violence is criminal behaviour and has tragic consequences in our society. Children are affected by domestic violence within the home even if they are not directly abused - many of the effects of witnessing domestic violence are the same as directly experiencing violence. The harmful effects of domestic violence can be seen on individual victims/survivors, their families, the community in which they live, and future generations. Domestic violence is the leading cause of injury to women, ahead of auto accidents, rapes and muggings combined. Although some women are successful in escaping a violent relationship after the first assault, most abuse is recurrent and escalates in both frequency and severity. In addition a woman's independence may be compromised by her partner's need to dominate her and control many aspects of her life. He may restrict her access to food, clothing, money, friends, transportation, health care or employment. It is important that we do not tolerate domestic violence nor regard it as less serious than other forms of violent crime. 2.1 Forms of Violence in RelationshipsViolence in relationships can take many forms. The aim of all such forms of violence is to assert power and control, and to remind the woman that (in the mind of the perpetrator) she is subordinate, inferior and worthless. The abusive person benefits from their actions by having the woman's undivided attention, getting his own needs and wants met, and feeling important and powerful. Emotional/Psychological AbuseThis is where the perpetrator does or says things that make their partner feel scared or intimidated. Some examples include threatening to harm or kill, constant criticism, threats to abduct or harm children, hurting or killing pets, threatening with the guns or other weapons. Prolonged silence, doing things to confuse the person, withholding important information or exclusion from decision making, are all forms of psychological abuse. Damage to PropertyDamage to property occurs when the house, household furniture, or anything else that the victims owns or uses is damaged or broken. This includes breaking plates, kicking holes in walls, or damaging cars. Social AbusePerpetrators often aim to control all aspects of their partner's life. Social abuse involves manipulation, isolation and/or intimidation. A survivor may be prevented from making contact with family and friends. Restricting use of the telephone or the family car or using insults, shaming and public humiliation are all forms of social abuse. Social and emotional abuse can be easily overlooked, yet their impact on psychological well-being is enormous. Physical AbusePhysical abuse is defined as the use of physical force with the intent to harm or frighten, and includes the use of weapons. Neglect can also be seen as a form of physical abuse. The majority of domestic violence victims will, at some point, suffer physical abuse. Their injuries range from bruising, broken bones, head injuries or nervous breakdown. Sexual AbuseSexual abuse is forced sexual activity including rape. Unwanted kissing or touching, or forcing someone to do something they don't want to do (eg. looking at pornography) is also sexual abuse. Financial AbuseControlling money by denying access to bank accounts, forcing the surrender of bankcards to gain control of a partner's income, preventing them to seek or maintain employment, and denying input into financial decisions are all examples of financial abuse. Spiritual AbuseSpiritual abuse undermines the victim's self-identity by behaviours such as criticising their spiritual beliefs; the quoting of religious texts to justify abusive behaviour; and abusing in ways that involve symbols of religion or spirituality. 2.2 The Cycle of AbuseThe Cycle of Violence is one model for understanding violent behaviour in an intimate relationship. The cycle of violence was developed by Lenore Walker in the 1970s, who through her work with a large number of victims of domestic violence identified a common pattern that the violence often took. The cycle of violence does not apply to all violent relationships, for example some victims identify that there is no 'honeymoon' phase in their relationship. The length of each phase varies on an individual basis - some victims may experience the entire cycle several times in a day, for other others it may take weeks to complete a cycle.
Build-up PhaseThis time is characterised by increasing tension between the couple. As tension builds the perpetrator's behaviour becomes more aggressive and intense regardless of how hard the victim tries to calm him. Stand-over PhaseIn this phase the perpetrator begins to use aggression and violence to frighten and control his partner. Explosion PhaseA violent outburst occurs. These outbursts are likely to intensify over time. After the assault the perpetrator enters the remorse phase. Remorse PhaseThe offender may feel ashamed and guilty, however, he will usually deny or underestimate the violence and refuse to take responsibility for his actions. He may claim that she is responsible for the violence because she provoked him, because she deserves it or because he did not realise what he was doing. The woman may go along with her partner because to do otherwise could mean acknowledging the terror and the danger in which she is living. Pursuit PhaseThe perpetrator attempts to convince his partner that he needs her. This is also known as the "Buy-Back" Phase because he will try to buy back his partner by presenting her with gifts, being loving and attentive. He may also promise that he will never hurt her again. If the buy-back attempts do not work he is likely to use threats and violence. This can be a life-threatening time for the victim. If a woman decides to leave her partner, he may threaten her that if she does not come back he will make her life as difficult as possible, in areas such as property, finance, children, relatives etc. Alternatively, he may become helpless, saying that he will commit suicide if she does not come back to him. Many women return, feeling needed, protecting him from harm, or scared that if they do not come back he may carry out his threats. Honeymoon PhaseThere is a high degree of intimacy where neither wants to remember the pain of the violence and earlier difficulties are denied. He may be attentive to her needs, communicative and she hopes and believes that he has changed. Unfortunately, in violent relationships, the cycle will often repeat itself again. Source of information: National Clearinghouse on Domestic Violence (1991) Washington: U.S. Government Printing Office, USA.3.0 EFFECTS OF DV ON WOMEN AND CHILDREN3.1 Effects on WomenSelf-EsteemOur self-esteem or self-concept is a measure of how we feel about ourselves. Low self-esteem creates feelings of self-doubt and worthlessness, taking away the self-confidence needed to make decisions and to solve problems. When our own feelings and judgment cannot be trusted, solving even small problems becomes difficult. In many cases low self-esteem and poor self-concept may lead to depression. Low self-esteem can also result in a disregard for personal appearance and health. Feelings of HelplessnessIn abusive relationships, the abusive man maintains control of his partner's actions by physically, sexually, and psychologically abusing her. If the assaulted woman tries to regain some control, the abuser may become more controlling. Her repeated unsuccessful attempts at stopping his violence reinforce her feelings of helplessness. As a result the assaulted woman may give up trying to break the cycle of violence. Self-Blame and GuiltMany women are used to looking after the emotional needs of their families. When the emotional well-being of the family is suffering, as it does when abuse is present, the woman can tend to blame herself and believe she is failing in her role to 'look after' her family. Some women have hidden the abuse for years because of the guilt and shame they feel. The partner usually encourages this thinking by blaming her for the abuse. This results in the woman falsely believing she has failed as an emotional caretaker and that she causes and deserves the abuse. Denying and MinimizingAlthough ineffective, denying and minimizing abuse are two ways of coping with his violence. They increase the danger already present by encouraging the victim to disregard signals, which can warn her of further assaults. Abused women frequently deny being victims of domestic violence and that a pattern of abuse has been established. A false sense of responsibility for the violence and embarrassment may prevent her from telling others about it. Excuses may be sought by the victim to explain away the violence and to renew hope for the relationship. Minimizing abuse downplays its seriousness. Often women avoid accepting the reality that they are being abused by comparing themselves to others who have endured more extreme acts of physical and psychological abuse. Their own situations then seem much less serious and much less dangerous. Drug and Alcohol AbuseVictims of domestic violence suffer from stress and tension. Many abused women turn to drugs and alcohol to avoid confronting their abusive situations. Continued used of these substances leads to dependency for many women. The abused partner who tries to deal effectively with her substance dependence and her violent situation at the same time can become easily overwhelmed. Alcohol and illegal drugs are obvious examples, but abuse of prescription drugs accounts for much of the substance abuse among women who experienced violence. Sleeping pills, painkillers and tranquillisers are the more commonly abused prescription drugs. 3.2 Effects on ChildrenChildren living in violent homes may have witnessed verbal threats of injury, objects being thrown, floggings, threats with weapons, sexual torture, suicide attempts and murder. Children are not only witnesses to the violence but may also be assaulted during violent incidents. How children are affected by witnessing abuse depends on a number of factors such as their age when the abuse began, how their mother coped, and what help and support the child and mother received. Infants
Pre-school and school age childrenChildren deal with the stress of witnessing domestic violence in two ways:
they hold it inside (internalise) or they express it (externalise). Adolescents
Children 11 years and up don't usually blame themselves for the violence, but they don't necessarily assign responsibility to the abuser either. They may well excuse the abuser and may side with him because he has the power in the family. They may feel angry with their mother for not protecting herself or them from the violence. Source Of information: National Clearinghouse on Domestic Violence (1991), Washington: U.S. Government Printing Office, USA.4.0 WOMEN FROM SPECIFIC GROUPS IN SOCIETYIn addition to the common impacts of domestic violence, particular groups of women, such as pregnant women, Indigenous women, women from non-English speaking backgrounds and women with disabilities, will experience additional impacts from domestic violence. Here we will examine these specific impacts in more detail. 4.1 Pregnant womenThe number of unwanted and unplanned pregnancies and terminations is higher among women experiencing domestic violence. Pregnancy itself is a time of heightened risk and the abdomen is targeted more frequently and more severely in pregnant women. Women experiencing violence during pregnancy often obtain minimal or late antenatal care. They are at increased risk of having poor weight gain, anaemia, infections, or pre-term labour; of bearing a low birth- weight infant; and experiencing postnatal depression. They are also more likely to engage in behaviours harmful to health, such as smoking, drinking excessive amounts of alcohol and substance misuse (Astbury, J .& Atkins n, J. & Duke, J.E.(2000).The impact of domestic violence on individuals (online). http://www.mja.com.au/public/issues/173_08_161000/astburby/astburby.html) 4.2 Issues for indigenous womenAccording to a 1994 study in Western Australia, Aboriginal women are 45 times
more likely to be victims of domestic violence than Anglo women. Most Aboriginal
women have been directly involved in, or have a close relationship with someone
who is involved in, domestic violence. The Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander
Women's Task Force on Violence report indicates that: What can you do?
4.3 Women from Non-English Speaking BackgroundsThe lack of information and resources about domestic violence protection orders in different languages prevents women:
Strategies based solely on the experiences of "Anglo-Australian" women are limited in their assistance to women from non-English speaking backgrounds. While there are similarities for women from all cultures and races in their experiences of domestic violence, additional barriers exist which must be addressed before effective assistance can be provided for women of non-English speaking backgrounds. These additional barriers arise from issues of ethnicity, race, class, immigration and/or refugee experiences. It is not that culture and race cause women of non-English speaking backgrounds to become victims of domestic violence, but culture and race impact on a women's access to appropriate assistance in dealing with the domestic violence. There are many obstacles for NESB women to overcome in accessing information, support services and legal systems:
Non-English speaking background women's perceptions, experiences and expectations of the legal and administrative system in Australia vary considerably. Many are fearful, particularly those who came from oppressive regimes, many are cynical, and many expect processes to be corrupt. Many women have no knowledge about the requirements of the domestic violence provisions in immigration law; are advised by their community to be a better wife and not embarrass their community by making trouble, and/or do not realise that domestic violence is a crime in Australia. How can you help?
4.4 Some issues for women with disabilitiesProblems experienced by women with disabilities in relation to domestic violence
include: What to take into account:
4.5 Same Sex RelationshipsDomestic violence also occurs in same sex relationships. At the root of the
violence are issues of power and control similar to those of heterosexual relationships.
The violence may involve the same types of violence as heterosexual couples.
In addition, threats such as publicising the victim's sexuality may also be
used to force compliance. What can you do:
1.Mulder.J. (1995.)Reclaiming our Rights, Australia. 2.National Clearinghouse on Domestic Violence (1991), Washington: U.S. Government Printing Office, USA. 3.Donnan, S. (2001). Domestic abuse of Aboriginal women exposed, Sydney, Australia. 4.W.I.S.E. (1991) .Consultation with Aboriginal Communities, Melbourne, Australia. 5 Eastern Perth Public and Community Health Unit (2001). Responding to Family & Domestic Violence- A guide for Health Care Professionals, State of Western Australia and the Department of Health. 6. Source of information: "The Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Women's Task Force on Violence Report" (March 2000) Queensland Government (Department of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Policy and Development). 5.0 RECOGNISING DOMESTIC VIOLENCEEarly detection of domestic violence is critical partly because domestic violence
episodes tend to increase and become more damaging over time. Being aware of
the warning signs and asking the patient the right questions will allow for
effective intervention.
5.1 Physical Signs of Violence:
Recurring abuse will often result in other illness and emotional problems that on the surface may not appear related to domestic violence:
5.3 Signs of Homicidal Risk:The risk of homicide is high and should be taken seriously if the perpetrator:
Information taken from: Eastern Perth Public and Community Health Unit (2001). Responding to Family & Domestic Violence- A guide for Health Care Professionals, State of Western Australia and the Department of Health. The following sections of the manual were developed to assist and serve as guidelines for general practitioners in their assessment and support of patients that are victims of domestic violence. There is no requirement to follow all the steps. GPs are always welcome to contact the Ipswich Women's Centre Against Domestic Violence (Ph: 3816 3000) at any time of their involvement with the patient. 6.0 ASSESSMENT AND CONFIDENTIALITYAssessmentWhat if a woman has suffered injuries? Consider the following:
ConfidentialityThere is often a fine line between the duty of care and confidentiality. Patient consent with respect to reporting incidents should be respected at all times. Encourage your patients to report incidents of domestic violence to the police or get their consent to you reporting incidents of domestic violence in response to sustained injury or abuse. Ideally this consent should be obtained in writing. All general practitioners owe their patients a duty of confidentiality. In the absence of consent, that duty can only be breached in some exceptional circumstances, such as where there is an overriding public interest. A breach of confidentiality must be fully documented. Source of information: Eastern Perth Public and Community Health Unit (2001). Responding to Family & Domestic Violence- A guide for Health Care Professionals, State of Western Australia and the Department of Health.7.0 HOW TO TALK TO YOUR PATIENTIt is very important to provide a supportive environment if you believe that your patient is a victim of domestic violence. You should encourage the victim to talk about her experience of abuse. The process of listening and validating is therapeutic in itself. Information obtained can assist you to assess immediate medical needs and safety risks:
Be firm about excluding others whose presence could interfere with your assessment. Asking about violenceThe detail of your questions will depend on how well you know the patient and
what indicators you have observed. For example:
Examples of specific questions linked to your observations may include:
Examples of direct questions include:
Your role is to:
Never:
Source of information: 8.0 THE EXAMINATIONAlways examine the woman separately from the suspected perpetrator, be sensitive to her needs and try to understand how difficult this may be for her. 8.1 Physical examination
8.2 Psychological assessment
8.3 Assessment of her social situation should include:
Source of information: Eastern Perth Public and Community Health Unit (2001). Responding to Family & Domestic Violence- A guide for Health Care Professionals, State of Western Australia and the Department of Health. 9.0 CLINICAL AND ETHICAL GUIDELINES FOR MEDICAL PRACTITIONERS WHO HAVE ABUSED WOMEN AND THEIR PARTNER AS PATIENTS
Information taken from: Eastern Perth Public and Community Health Unit (2001). Responding to Family & Domestic Violence- A guide for Health Care Professionals, State of Western Australia and the Department of Health. 10.0 DOCUMENTATIONCase notes should be written with a clear understanding that the information can be used for legal purposes in the future. Clear and accurate case note records will:
Information taken from: Eastern Perth Public and Community Health Unit (2001). Responding to Family & Domestic Violence- A guide for Health Care Professionals, State of Western Australia and the Department of Health. 11.0 SAFETY PLANNINGSafety is the paramount issue in responding to domestic violence:
Source of Information: Domestic Violence Resource Centre (1999) "Reaching Out-a domestic violence resource for family and friends", G & E Printing, Australia. 12.0 DOMESTIC VIOLENCE AND THE LAWVictims of domestic, family and dating violence; and of abuse in informal care relationships, can seek protection by applying at the local Magistrate Court for a Protection Order. Each state and territory in Australia has its own legislation dealing with protection for victims of domestic violence. They may be named differently in each state or territory but they serve the same purpose of preventing future abusive behaviour. What is a Protection Order?Protection Orders are court orders designed to prevent future violence and abuse by describing behaviour that a violent person may not engage in. The perpetrator of the abuse will not have a criminal record unless he breaches the conditions of the order. Who can apply?
What relationships are covered?Spousal Relationships
Intimate Personal Relationships
Family Relationships
Informal Care Relationships
Where do you apply?
How can you help:
Source of Information: The Domestic and Family violence protection Act 1989-information pamphlet, 2003,Violence prevention Unit, Department of Families, Australia 13.0 REFERRALIt is now accepted that no agency acting in isolation can hope to provide the diversity of support services required for victims of domestic violence. Domestic violence intervention is a complex task requiring a multidisciplinary framework, involving parties such as police, justice, welfare and health services working in partnership with community based organizations such as domestic violence services and advice and referral services. Before making a referral ensure that you have the following information:
Provide a history of the abuse and any significant facts that may be of use such as:
A woman may choose to return home to an abusive relationship. Respect this choice. Encourage her that support is there should she require it in the future. Provide contact numbers for support agencies. Information taken from: Eastern Perth Public and Community Health Unit (2001). Responding to Family & Domestic Violence- A guide for Health Care Professionals, State of Western Australia and the Department of Health
|